A story about a sandbox, professional judgment, and the role of Quality Assurance.
This article is part of our Quality Management Series — practical guidance on designing, managing, and improving Quality in Customer Service and Contact Centers.
This article is part of our Contact Center Management Series — a collection of articles that bring together practical guidance and insights to help Contact Centers run better and deliver stronger results.
Sometimes the most important thing you hear on a Customer call has nothing to do with the Advisor handling it.
Cindy Looked Concerned
When Cindy, our Head of Quality Assurance, walked into my office, she looked concerned.
“Dan, I just listened to the weirdest call. You know the new children’s sandbox we’re selling in this month’s catalog? The one that ships directly from the UK?”
“Sure, Cindy — I know the one — it comes with a wind-down roof and looks quite fancy. Why?”
“Well, a Customer in Florida just had her sandbox delivered, and she called to say it’s defective. Apparently, there’s no bottom in it.”
“No bottom in the sandbox? What do you mean?”
“It seems to be missing a floorboard. The Customer described it as only a frame with the wind-down roof. When you fill it up, you’d have to pour the sand directly on the ground.”
We looked at each other for a moment.
Don’t all sandboxes have bottoms?
The Context
In the 1990s, I was VP of Contact Center & Distribution Operations for a Los Angeles-based direct marketing company serving Customers across the U.S.
The company sold a variety of products, including country music CDs, children’s toys, and gardening tools, through TV commercials and catalogs.
We were always busy during the holiday season, but we were also overwhelmed with orders and service enquiries whenever a beloved music artist passed away.
Not exactly an event you could put into a forecast.
Our distribution centers shipped most Customer orders. But larger products, like the children’s sandbox, were sometimes shipped directly from the manufacturer.
In this case, the sandbox came directly from the UK.
And as we’d soon discover, that detail mattered.
What Our Marketing People Told Us
I got on the phone with our product expert in Marketing and explained what Cindy had heard on the Customer’s call.
After looking into it, she came back to me and explained that, according to our supplier, it was common in the UK for sandboxes to be designed without a floorboard.
Once the package was received, Customers chose the location, put the frame together, and poured sand directly on the ground until it reached the top of the frame.
For the manufacturer in the UK, it was business as usual.
But for the Customer in Florida, that looked like a product defect.
What We Did Next
Thanks to Cindy and informed by the discussion with Marketing, we were on it.
Nearly 40 sandboxes — each costing over $1,000 — were still being packed for shipment.
That gave us the opportunity to reach out to each Customer, explain the product design, and let them decide whether to keep their order or cancel it.
For Customers who cancelled, we offered a substantial gift voucher toward their next order.
For Customers who decided to keep the sandbox, we thanked them with a discount on their order.
It turned out that the vast majority of the Customers decided to keep the sandbox.
We made sure to capture what our sandbox Customers told us so that Marketing could update the catalog copy for future mailings and we could update our Advisor knowledge base.
A common thread running through these Customer conversations was that they appreciated that we reached out and gave them a choice.
An early lesson in the use of qualitative research and using Customer insight.
The Power of the Quality Assurance Role
The Quality Assurance role is sometimes underestimated and underutilized.
It’s so much more than a policing function for Advisors — a framing that positions the role as low-level and punitive.
In this story, Cindy acted as a lighthouse for quality issues. She had the judgment to recognize when an unusual call deserved our attention.
She didn’t just score the call — she surfaced a systemic risk that could have impacted many of our best Customers.
Would today’s automated Quality Assurance systems recognize the significance of that conversation, or simply evaluate whether the Advisor handled it correctly?
Though this story is decades old, it still has a profound impact on how I look at Quality. And it remains one of the many real-life stories I share when I teach Quality Assurance.
Thank you, Cindy, for showing me early on what a great Quality Assurance professional can do.
Continue Exploring
We Have a Quality Program. So Why Isn’t Quality Improving?
15 Quiz Questions on Quality Assurance (Part 1)
Your Super-High Quality Scores May Be Holding Your Team Back
Thank You for Reading
I regularly share stories, strategies, and insights from our work across Contact Centers, Customer Service, and Customer Experience. If this resonates, I’d love to stay connected.
You can drop me a line anytime, or subscribe on our site.
Daniel Ord
[email protected]
www.omnitouchinternational.com



