How to Make Better Decisions: Stop Leading with Opinion

A painter examines a museum portrait closely with a magnifying glass, carrying an easel and paint palette, in Norman Rockwell’s humorous 1955 illustration “The Art Critic.”

When you want to make better decisions, don’t rely on your opinion.

This article introduces our Leadership Seriesreflections on inspiration, influence, and the choices that shape meaningful achievement.


Design thinking creates solutions that aren’t that obvious. Danny Kuivenhoven, Global Head of AI

When Someone Asks, “Dan, What Do You Think?”

People sometimes ask me about my best Customer Experience.
Or the best Service interaction I’ve ever had.

I always hesitate to answer — not because I lack opinions, but because I don’t see myself as the arbiter of what’s best.

“The best” belongs to the beholder:
the Passenger, Patient, Client, Guest — or for my work, the Training Participant.

As marketing strategist Mark Ritson warns:

All your thoughts, feelings and immediate responses … are not just incorrect — they are dangerous. — Mark Ritson, The first rule of marketing is you are not the customer

His point is simple and crucial:
confusing what I like with what Customers value is risky business.


It’s Not About My Opinion

In 25 years of delivering professional training, no Client has ever said:

Dan, we’re flying you to Shanghai, Brussels, or Phoenix so you can talk about your opinions. Everyone is dying to know what you think.

Did you wince when you read that?
I did.

Because in workshops, my role isn’t to pontificate.

It’s to share frameworks, tools, and approaches that help people see and navigate the world differently.

Better listening.
Stronger Contact Centers.
Clearer communication.
Smarter handling of difficult situations.

Approaches people can use — and make their own.

Related reading: The Curse of Knowledge: A Cognitive Bias Explained


Let’s Talk About Judgment

Every effective discipline combines:

  • a method, and
  • judgment

I started my career in finance.

We would prepare the formal budget — following the required protocols — and then came the interesting part:

Working with stakeholders to interpret what the numbers meant
and where to adjust assumptions based on experience and shared judgment.

Last week, I taught Contact Center forecasting.

We worked through the math first — time series methodology.

But the value isn’t the calculation itself.
It’s the application of judgment:

  • What might make volume go up or down?
  • What could push AHT higher or lower?
  • What’s happening now that the past doesn’t reveal?

As I teach it:

Just because the past is a good basis for predicting the future doesn’t mean the future will look exactly like the past.

That’s the moment to apply judgment.

I summarize it this way:

Don’t lead with opinion and skip the relevant framework.
Lead with the relevant framework — and then apply sound judgment.


A Real-Life Example

In a People Management class, we were discussing interviewing.
Several seasoned Customer Service Managers said things like:

  • “It takes me five minutes to know if someone is right for the job.”
  • “I can just tell — I’ve been doing this a long time.”
  • “If a candidate pauses too much, they’re not suited for Customer Service.”

My interest wasn’t whether they had earned wisdom.

It was what they were leading with:
their personal opinions.

And here’s the issue:

  • Personal opinion is hard to scale.
  • When they move companies, the “magic method” leaves with them.
  • And worst of all — they may be wrong.

Bias is a terrible hiring tool.

That’s why we teach structured interviewing:

  • A standardized set of numerically scored questions
  • Asked of every candidate for a role
  • Scored by one or more interviewers
  • Combined with other designed data points

Then — and only then — do you apply judgment:

Yes, Tanya scored highest. But our judgment is that Theresa is a better cultural fit. So we’ll offer her the job.

That’s intentional judgment.
Not gut feel.


I Don’t Rely on Opinion

When I’m facilitating, I put my opinions aside.

What I bring instead are:

  • frameworks,
  • methodologies,
  • structured approaches, and
  • stories from Clients across industries

Because the “best experience” varies widely depending on context, culture, and intent.

So when someone asks me for my personal “best” experience, I usually say:

I don’t think my personal opinion matters much here.
Let’s use a robust, relevant process — and then apply sound judgment to what the process reveals.

Whether we’re hiring, forecasting, budgeting, designing a new experience, or even writing an email:

Follow a strong approach.
Then apply your judgment — earned through experience — to shape the outcome.

That’s where better results come from.

Related reading: Values Don’t Mean Much If They Don’t Cost You Something


Leadership Articles

Practical lessons on leadership, judgment, and learning — drawn from experience at work and in life.


Thank You for Reading

I regularly share stories, strategies, and insights from our work across Contact Centers, Customer Service, and Customer Experience.  If this resonates, I’d love to stay connected.

You can drop me a line anytime, or subscribe on our site.

Daniel Ord
[email protected]
www.omnitouchinternational.com

Leadership
Send me a message